Me and My PD – Misdiagnosis and Confirmation Bias

Non-Artificial Intelligence Summary: The author reveals that he was misdiagnosed with Parkinson’s Disease (PD) over 13 years ago, after initially seeking treatment for Essential Tremors (ET). The article concludes with a link to an open access article on Six Myths and Misconceptions about Essential Tremor.

_________________________

Over the summer of 2025, I’ve been undergoing review of my movement disorders, with a reduction in medications as well as no clinical observation of Parkinson’s Disease (PD) symptoms.

Some thirteen or so years ago, after a neurologist or nurse practitioner observed some slight rigidity, providing enough symptoms to make a clinical diagnosis, an old high school girlfriend called to express some concern and to wish me the best. Apparently, she was under the misconception that PD was equivalent to a slow death. Glad to say she must be mighty disappointed after all these years.

I had essential tremors (ET) from my teen years, in addition to several other prodromal conditions or symptoms relating to PD. In 2010 the ET had become somewhat disabling, and after many months of unsuccessful treatment for ET, I opted for Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS), which apparently had a great success rate with ET. However, in order to rule out PD, several months of tests were undergone, with the eventual three of four of the cardinal signs being observed. DBS was scheduled less than two months later. Seven years later, due to a lack of progressive neurological deterioration, a DAT Scan was ordered, with an interpretation that I apparently did have some form of parkinsonism. Apparently, the original diagnosis of PD was premature and made under the influence of confirmation bias. Or, to paraphrase Paul Simon, a person sees what they want to see and disregards the possibility of other underlying causes for a barely detectable symptom.

Finally, after moving to a different state and establishing care with a Movement Disorder Specialist, who conducted their own evaluation on and off PD medications, the original problem (ET) which brought me to a neurologist in 2010, was confirmed. The process of titrating off medications continues.

Naturally, I have been delving into the National Institutes of Health open access in order to learn more about what has been called “familial tremors” and “benign tremors” in the past.

One thing I have learned is the diagnosis of ET and PD can be difficult, due to many overlapping symptoms or conditions, they are linked genetically for some ET cases, and much of the material on PD doesn’t even investigate whether the two conditions are concurrent.

So another reason for me to go on living: educate and advocate for people who may or may not have a diagnosis appropriate to their condition.

We’ll start here, with a recent article on Six Myths and Misconceptions about Essential Tremor.

Music, music music (and exercise)

Dial the wayback machine to 2021, where this digital commons paper from Sacred Heart University on Influence and Effect of Music on Exercise  By Kendall Stewart appeared.

… Lack of adherence to exercise and physical activity, and related programs, is correlated with absence of motivation and enjoyment. Research has proven the presence of music, during physical activity, to be a strong motivator and linked to increased enjoyment, thus increasing exercise adherence. The purpose of this essay is to compile research in order to analyze and explain how the presence of music during physical activity increases mood and affective state of mind to bring about increased adherence and motivation as well as describe how individuals feel as though they are doing less work/exercising less when listening to music while being physically active. In addition, … examine the effect that different music genres, speeds, paces, and preferences have on exercise performance, enjoyment and adherence. (emphasis added).

Among the citations are:

de Dreu MJ, van der Wilk ASD, Poppe E, Kwakkel G, van Wegen EEH. Rehabilitation,
exercise therapy and music in patients with Parkinson’s disease: A meta-analysis of the
effects of music-based movement therapy on walking ability, balance and quality of life.
Parkinsonism & Related Disorders. 2012;18(Suppl 1):S114-S119. doi:10.1016/S1353-
8020(11)70036-0

which also refers to:

Goodwin VA, Richards SH, Taylor RS, Taylor AH, Campbell JL. The effectiveness of exercise interventions for people with Parkinson’s disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Mov Disord. 2008 Apr 15;23(5):631-40. doi: 10.1002/mds.21922. PMID: 18181210.

Evidence supported exercise as being beneficial with regards to physical functioning, health-related quality of life, strength, balance and gait speed for people with PD. There was insufficient evidence support or refute the value of exercise in reducing falls or depression.

On the topic of music and PD, we have:

Poliakoff, E., Bek, J., Phillips, M., Young, W. R., & Rose, D. C. (2023). Vividness and Use of Imagery Related to Music and Movement in People with Parkinson’s: A Mixed-methods Survey Study. Music & Science, 6. https://doi.org/10.1177/20592043231197919

excerpts from the abstract (as always, emphasis added):

… Music is used in interventions for people with Parkinson’s, either to pace movements, or as an integral element of activities such as dance. This study explored self-reported vividness of two forms of imagery – motor imagery evoked by music and auditory (including musical) imagery – in people with Parkinson’s, and whether and how they use these types of imagery in everyday life.

Participants (N = 199) completed:

(i) vividness ratings of visual and kinesthetic music-evoked motor imagery,

(ii) vividness ratings of auditory imagery, and

(iii) ratings and open questions about their everyday use of these types of imagery.

…  <20% reported actively using music to support motor imagery in daily activities. In contrast, participants reported a broad range of contexts and uses for musical imagery (imagined music), from supporting movement (e.g., walking or exercise) to emotion regulation, and concentration.

Correlational analyses associated vividness of music- evoked motor imagery with an urge to dance and musical training, while the use of musical imagery was associated with singing ability.

A minority of participants reported not experiencing either motor or musical imagery, suggesting that interventions based on imagery may not be suitable for all.

even participants with more severe motor symptoms reported experiencing and using both types of imagery, indicating promise for their strategic use at different stages of Parkinson’s. … musical and motor imagery have the potential to support rehabilitation strategies for Parkinson’s, either separately or in combination.

Not the “hardest” scientific evidence there is, but hey, Einstein (a guy who only has to be referred to by his surname, and we all know who were talking about) reported that he did his though experiments using visual imagery, and only later (and with much labor) worked out the math. (I believe the reference can be found in a book “The Act of Creation” by Arthur Koestler, if memory serves. As Einstein reportedly said, you can always look it up).

How to end this post on music and Parkinson’s Disease? Rather than submit one of my own YouTube videos, how about one from another person whose first name alone is sufficient to identify him:

Elvis